Education Is Not Medicine

One of the popular new reformster talking points is to compare standardized testing to diagnostic testing at the doctor's office (you...

One of the popular new reformster talking points is to compare standardized testing to diagnostic testing at the doctor's office (you can find examples here and here). This comparison is total baloney, and reformsters need to retire it immediately. They are just making themselves look silly. Let's break it down.

Students are not patients.

Students are not patients who need to be "cured" of the "disease" of not knowing stuff. There is nothing about that comparison that holds up. Disease attacks a healthy body and breaks down tissues and functions that were previously fine. Which part of that sounds like a student not understanding how to multiply double digit numbers or misunderstanding how to find verbs?

Doctors choose the tests.

The doctor uses her professional judgment to determine which tests will be administered. The doctor uses her professional judgment looking at the symptoms, the nature of the patient and the possible issues that might be involved. And then the doctor decides which test to order because

There are many tests.

Doctors do not have a single one size fits all diagnostic test that is given to all patients, regardless of whether they are complaining about a sore chest, a broken leg, or a high fever. The test is chosen to fit the situation (again, using the doctor's professional judgment). For that matter, for every test the doctor chooses to give a patient, the doctor also choose NOT to give a large number of tests to that patient. There is no medical analog for a high stakes one size fits all test to be given to all students.

Doctors can still see.

When I went to the doctor with the flesh of my knee split open, my doctor did not say, "Well, it looks like the flesh of your knee is split open, and I might be looking at the patella right there, but let me run some tests, first." He definitely didn't say, "First, I have to give you this exact same test that we give every single patient who enters the hospital no matter what the issue seems to be." Because, as it turns out, my doctor has A) eyes and B) sense. So he sewed up my knee. Some times the correct diagnostic test is no test at all, because A) eyes and B) sense.

Results are timely.

Depending on the urgency of the situation (as determined by the professional judgment of the doctor), the results will come back in a timely manner. If you get your broken leg x-rayed in May, your doctor expects to see the images before September.

Judgment beats test

When the test results return, the doctor makes a diagnosis and prescription based on his professional judgment. The test provides data; it does not make a prescription. "The test says I have to prescribe paxil for you," said no doctor ever. The doctor's judgment is not subordinate to the test results.

Doctors know when to quit

My doctor does not shorten my treatment so that he has time to give me more tests. If he has to make a choice between more treatment for my problem and more testing, more testing does not automatically win.

No stakes tests.

The diagnostic tests that a doctor orders do not become part of the job evaluation of the doctor. The hospital board does not call a doctor in and say, "One hundred percent of the limbs you ordered x-rays for this year were broken. Therefor we find you ineffective and you're fired." Nor do we use the test results to judge the hospital. And we especially don't use the test results to judge people in some other department who never even saw the patient.

So stop comparing high stakes standardized tests to diagnostic medical tests. They are not comparable and the analogy is extraordinarily weak. Find something else better to compare high stakes standardized tests to, like cumquats or people who insist on talking loudly on their cell phones in public places.

Furthermore

COMMENTS

Όνομα

-17 βαθμούς Κελσίου 'Ακης Τσοχατζόπουλος 17 Νοέμβρη 17Ν 1994 404 error --Greece-- not found Α' Παγκόσμιος Πόλεμος Άγαλμα Στάλιν Άγγελος Φιλιππίδης Αγορά Ακρωτηριασμός ζώων Αλέξης Τσίπρας Αντώνη Σαμαρά Αντώνης Σαμαράς απαγωγή Απόστολος Γκλέτσος Αριέλ Σαρόν Αρτέμης Σώρρας Αρχαία Ελληνικά Αστικές συγκοινωνίες ΑΣΤΥΝΟΜΙΑ Βίντεο Βόλφγκανγκ Σόιμπλε Γ. Μπέλτσιος ΓΑΔΑ γαλλική πρεσβεία Γενικός Γραμματέας Δημοσίων Εσόδων Γέρων Παϊσιος Γιάννης Στουρνάρας Γιώργος Γερμενής Γιώργος Κουρής Γιώργος Μαριδάκης Γιώργος Παπακωνσταντίνος Γνώμες Δ. Κοντομηνάς ΔΕΗ Δελτίο καιρού Δημήτρης Δασκαλόπουλος Δημήτρης Κοντομηνάς Δημόσιο Δημόσιοι υπάλληλοι Δημοψήφισμα διαδίκτυο των πραγμάτων διαδίκτυο των ρομπότ Διαφήμιση ΔΟΥ Έγκλημα Έκθεση έκθεση φωτογραφίας Εκκλησία εκλογές 2014 Εκλογές των ΗΠΑ Εκπτώσεις Ελ Γκρέκο ελαιόλαδο Ελευθέριος Βενιζέλος ελιά Ελλάδα ελληνικά Ναυπηγεία Σκαραμαγκά Ελληνική Αστυνομία ελληνική ταυτότητα ελληνικό χρέος ελληνικός βυθός ΕΛΤΑ ΕΜΥ εξοπλιστικά Επιδόματα Επικοινωνία Εργασία Ευρωζώνη ζεύγος Γριβέα Ζίγκμουντ Φρόιντ ηλεκτρονικό νόμισμα ηλιακή ενέργεια Ηλίας Κασιδιάρης Θέατρο Θέρμανση Θησαυροφυλάκιο Θώμη Κουμπούρα ΙΚΑ ΙΣΘΜΟΣ ΤΗΣ ΚΟΡΙΝΘΟΥ Ισπανικό φιάσκο Ιστορία ΙΧ Ιωάννης Μπέλτσιος Καιρός Καραμούζης κατασχέσεις Καύσιμα Κοινωνία Κόσμος Κρήτη κυβέρνηση κύμα γρίπης Κυριάκος Μητσοτάκης Κώστας Κόλλιας Κώστας Μπακογιάννης λαχανικά ΛΗΣΤΕΙΑ λίστα Λαγκάρντ Λογοτεχνία Μανώλης Καραμολέγκος Μαρινόπουλος Μαφία Μαχόμενες Λαϊκές Επαναστατικές Ομάδες μίζες μικρή Μαρία Μιχάλη Λιάπη Μιχάλης Λιάπης Μνημόνιο Μόνος στο Σπίτι Μπόμπολας μωρό του Σατανά Νίκος Μιχαλολιάκος Ντόναλντ Τράμπ Ο έλλην βρυκόλαξ οικογενειακά επιδόματα Οικονομία οικονομική στήριξη ομοφυλοφιλικές σχέσεις Παναγιώτης Ηλιόπουλος Πανελλαδική συγκέντρωση διαμαρτυρίας εκπαιδευτικών Πάρκινσον ΠΑΣΟΚ Περιβάλλον Περίεργα πινακίδες Πληρωμές ανα δήμο ποινικοποίηση Πολιτική Πολιτισμός Προβόπουλος Πρόεδρος του Ταχυδρομικού Ταμιευτηρίου Προνοιακά επιδόματα Πρόσωπα πρώην πρωθυπουργός του Ισραήλ ρεκόρ Γκίνες Σάββας Ξηρός Σάλλας σάντουιτς ΣΔΟΕ ΣΕΒ Σπύρος Ριζόπουλος Στ. Στασινόπουλος Στάθης Μπούκουρας Σταύρος Ψυχάρης στέλεχος των Ελληνικών Ναυπηγείων Συνέντευξη ΣΥΡΙΖΑ Σχιζοφρενής Σωτ. Εμμανουήλ Σωτήρης Εμμανουήλ Ταχυδρομικό Ταμιευτή ριο Ταχυδρομικό Ταμιευτήριο Τεχνολογία τζακ ποτ Τζόκερ Τοπικά Τράπεζα Πειραιώς Τράπεζες τραπεζικά σκάνδαλα Τρόϊκα τυριά Τaxis. Υγεία υπ.Υγείας Υπουργείο Διοικητικής Μεταρρύθμισης υπουργείου Διοικητικής Μεταρρύθμισης υπουργός Οικονομικών Φεστιβάλ Φίλιππος Λοίζος φρούτα φυλακές Κορυδαλλού φυλακές Λάρισας Φυλλάδια Lidl Φωτογραφίες Χ.Α. ΧΑ Χάκερ Χαμόγελο του Παιδιού Χαρ. Γιαγκούδης χαράτσι για τη λιακάδα Χημικά όπλα Χίτλερ Χρήστος Μπαλαντίνας Χρήστος Παππάς Χριστόδουλος Ξηρος Χριστόδουλος Ξηρός Χρυσή Αυγή adrian peterson biography adrian peterson career stats adrian peterson draft class adrian peterson injury adrian peterson stats adrian peterson workout advertise advertise meaning advertise online for free all blogger tricks amendment 2 Antichrist Superstar AOL Weird News Apple arouraios Asbestos Lung Cancer Baywash Bikini Car Wash Bikini Car Wash Bitcoin blogger tricks 2013 blogger tricks 2014 blogger tricks and hacks blogger tricks and tips blogger tricks and tools blogger tricks in urdu blogger widgets Business Business Voip Solutions buyer mortgage note can i make money from internet Car insurance quotes pa Cassandra De Pecol demo Donate car to charity California Donate your car Sacramento dreamweaver free templates download Drug War Marijuana DUCHESNE COUNTY e-branch earn money from facebook earn money from facebook account earn money from facebook like earn money from facebook likes earn money from google EBOLA Editorial equity rates Eva Longoria Facebook FIMOTRO florida amendment 2 Florida Marijuana FLU Forensics Online Course fox news free business templates download free css templates free flash templates download free flyer templates free html templates free html templates download free php templates download free powerpoint templates free ppt templates download free psd templates download free templates free templates download free templates for blogger free website templates download html and css free word templates free wordpress templates Gps Guide Stop Saying Sorry Apologizing Saying Sorry Emotional Wellness Happiness Happiness Today H1N1 HEALTH how can i earn money from facebook how to earn money from facebook groups how to earn money from facebook in hindi how to earn money from facebook pages how to earn money from website how to make money on internet for teenagers IFTTT Influenza (Flu) Injury Lawyers Instagram iPad JP Morgan Kaspersky Consumer Security Risks Kurt Cobain Legal Weed Florida make money from home make money from internet make money from internet without investment make money from youtube make money online Marijuana 420 Marijuana Medical Marijuana Prohibition Maxim Media Medical Marijuana MEDICAL WATCH Mesothelioma Law Firm Met Auto Mobile Banking Mortgage Adviser Motor Festival 2017 NEWS News > People News Feed News Florida off-shore Original Video perfect skin Pizza hut PRESS-GR.blogspot.com Royalty free images stock Simpsons Slider Spin Communications Steve McMahon SWINE FLU Things You Can't Do Naked top blogger tricks tromaktiko Twitter Video Viral War on Marijuana Weird Florida Weird News wisconsin election results wisconsin governor race www.rizopoulospost.com
false
ltr
item
Lamia24: Education Is Not Medicine
Education Is Not Medicine
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-9vPMksQ6PNY/VFt9F_ndJLI/AAAAAAAAfIM/JhmC3H5WZKE/s1600/1.jpg
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-9vPMksQ6PNY/VFt9F_ndJLI/AAAAAAAAfIM/JhmC3H5WZKE/s72-c/1.jpg
Lamia24
http://lamia24.blogspot.com/2014/11/education-is-not-medicine.html
http://lamia24.blogspot.com/
http://lamia24.blogspot.com/
http://lamia24.blogspot.com/2014/11/education-is-not-medicine.html
true
5103481857587148528
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All Σχετικά άρθρα Κατηγορία Αρχείο Αναζήτηση ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Επιστροφή στην αρχική Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy